| Reverend John Harrington | 1863-1863 | |
| Reverend Peter Joseph Grey | 1863-1868 | |
| Brother U. Justin McMahon |
1868-1879 |
|
 |
Brother Bettelin McMahon | 1879-1891 |
| Brother Cianan Griffin | 1891-1892 | |
 |
Brother Yvasian Michael Dorgan | 1892-1894 |
 |
Brother Erminold Walter O'Donnell | 1894-1895 |
| Brother Walter O'Melia | 1895-1900 | |
| Brother Erminold Walter O'Donnell | 1900-1902 | |
 |
Brother Zenonian Brannan | 1902-1904 |
 |
Brother Vellesian Mallon | 1904-1910 |
 |
Brother Florinus Peter Doyle | 1910-1911 |
 |
Brother Fabrician Pellerin | 1911-1914 |
| Brother Vellesian Mallon | 1914-1917 | |
| Brother Gregory Mallon | 1917-1922 | |
 |
Brother Vantasian Sharkey | 1922-1923 |
| Brother Gregory Mallon | 1923-1927 | |
 |
Brother U. Lewis Treacy | 1927-1930 |
 |
Brother Z. Leo Meehan | 1930-1932 |
 |
Brother Jasper Fitzsimmons | 1932-1935 |
 |
Brother U. Albert Rahill
|
1935-1941 |
 |
Brother Austin Crowley | 1941-1950 |
 |
Brother W. Thomas Levi | 1950-1956 |
 |
Brother S. Albert Plotz | 1956-1962 |
|
|
Brother Michael Quinn | 1962-1969 |
 |
Brother Mel Anderson | 1969-1997 |
 |
Brother Craig Franz | 1997-2004 |
 |
Brother Ronald Gallagher | 2005-2013 |
 |
James Donahue | 2013- |
